2021

Gracie Petry

Top 16 at Miss USA

2020

Sydney Taylor

4th Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2019

Emma Brooks McAllister

2018

Lindsey Conque

Top 10 at Miss Teen USA

2017

Hailey Crausby

2016

Ellie Picone

Top 15 at Miss Teen USA

2015

Katherine Haik

Miss Teen USA

2014

Mary Risener

2013

Bailey Hidalgo

Top 16 at Miss Teen USA

2012

Marlee Henry

2011

Elizabeth Heinen

2010

Brianna Waguespack

2009

Brittany Guidry

4th Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2008

Lindsey Evans

3rd Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2007

Logan Travis

2006

Kelsey Lawson

2005

Morgan Maulden

2004

Shelley Hennig

Miss Teen USA

2004

Keisha Barras

Succeeded Shelley Hennig

2003

Megan Bologna

2002

Candice Stewart

2001

Paige Egan

Top 10 at Miss Teen USA

2000

Nina Moch

1999

Sarah Thornhill

1st Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

1998

Jennifer Dupont

1997

Sarah Price

1996

Kimi Fairchild

1995

Shaun Price